Archive
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
Letter of the Week

Without peer

Tulloch in the spring of 1957 (as a three-year-old) was weighted like no other.
The VRC handicapper gave him 8.4 for the Melbourne Cup (52.5kg) — 12lb over weight-for-age. Phar Lap in his three-year-old year had 7.6 (47kg).
Owner E.A. Haley refused to run Tulloch with that weight.
Never has any three-year-old since been asked to carry 5kg over weight-for-age — perhaps no horse of any age has been asked to do it.
To me that handicap prevented Tulloch from completing the grand slam of racing.
Tulloch is the greatest colt this country has ever seen. He holds the Caulfield Cup record for 1½ miles and the Cox Plate record for 1¼ miles (from barrier 15).
During his career he won over 10 different distances. He came back and won after being gravely ill and missing nearly two years of racing.
He smashed Phar Lap’s record in winning the AJC Derby and was given 12lb more in the Cup.
He ran 110 yards (100.6m) further than Phar Lap in the Cox Plate and still ran a faster time.
And yet a leading Melbourne paper still regards Phar Lap as number one. Simply untrue.

Matt Baldwin
Wagga Wagga (NSW)
Today's Racing
Friday 29 March
Saturday 30 March
Sunday 31 March