Archive
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
Letter of the Week

Whippy-slappy, not happy-clappy

I read Adrian Dunn’s “Spare the rod ...” article (14/2). Sorry mate but horses race to win — it’s not meant to be a run in the park!
For every Bowman you see riding a Catkins out hands and heels to a narrow victory you’ll see 10 times as many jockeys get done in a close finish. It’s all very nice in this nanny state racing lives in now to give him a rap but what if he got beat? Surely it should be a mandatory suspension!
Give me Blake Shinn’s vigorous use of the whip in the final furlong every time to these quiet Corey Brown types. I use those two jockeys deliberately because in big races a couple of years ago it was Shinn who continually outrode Brown to get close photo finishes — Viewed’s Melbourne Cup for one.
Also take a look at the Epsom Handicap where Shinn beat Brown, riding five times as hard. Ridiculous, I say. Brown should have got suspended for denying his mount what should have been victory.
Remember the horse is a beast over 500kg, not a dog or a cat!
Racing has survived 150 years without these preachers telling us about overuse of the whip. It’ll survive another 150.

Alan Walker
Essendon (Vic)
Today's Racing
Thursday 8 May
Friday 9 May
Saturday 10 May